False Harassment Accusations: How California Employers Should Respond

FEHA / EEO Defense

7 mins read

7 mins read

False Harassment Accusations: How California Employers Should Respond

A harassment complaint does not become “false” simply because the evidence is weak, the accused denies it, or the investigation cannot substantiate the allegation.

For California employers, the first job is to investigate. The employer must respond promptly, protect against retaliation, give the accused a fair opportunity to respond, and document the evidence supporting the final finding.

The difficult question comes afterward: when does an unsubstantiated complaint remain protected, and when does the evidence support discipline for a knowingly fabricated accusation?

California law allows employers to act on genuinely false complaints, but the distinction between an unsubstantiated complaint and a fabricated one matters. This guide explains how employers can investigate, document, and respond without creating a retaliation or defamation problem of their own.

Key Takeaways

  • A complaint must be taken seriously even when the allegations initially appear weak. An inadequate response can contribute to liability under FEHA's duty to take reasonable steps to prevent and correct harassment.

  • If the employee reasonably and in good faith believed the reported conduct was unlawful, disciplining the employee because the complaint proved unsuccessful can create a risk of retaliation.

  • Joaquin v. City of Los Angeles (2012) recognizes that an employer may discipline an employee for a fabricated harassment complaint. But the employer must be able to defend the stated reason for discipline.

  • Investigation reports can create defamation exposure. Hearn v. PG&E (2025) involved a $2.16 million jury verdict, which was reversed on damages-duplication grounds.

  • Limit investigation communications to people with a legitimate need to know. California's common-interest privilege may protect certain internal communications made without malice, but unnecessary distribution or evidence of malice can create defamation risk.

How Do You Deal With a False Accusation of Harassment at Your Business?

Treat "false" as a finding rather than a starting assumption. Failing to investigate or prevent harassment is an independent claim under Gov. Code §12940(k), so skipping the investigation because the claim "can't be true" is the fastest route to liability.

Start with these steps:

  1. Preserve everything, including messages, schedules, and prior complaints involving the same people.

  2. Separate the parties' reporting lines while you investigate.

  3. Investigate promptly with a neutral person.

  4. Reach a written finding, then act proportionately.

Here is how each outcome is typically handled:

Complaint outcome

What it means

Can employer discipline complainant?

Substantiated

Evidence supports the allegation

Potentially take corrective action against the accused

Unsubstantiated

Evidence is insufficient to establish the allegation

Not merely because it was unsubstantiated

Inconclusive

Evidence conflicts or cannot establish what occurred

Not merely because the evidence is inconclusive

Knowingly fabricated

Evidence supports a conclusion that the employee deliberately made a false allegation

Potentially, if supported by the evidence and applicable policy

Is a False Accusation of Harassment Illegal, and Can You Discipline the Employee Who Made It?

Not automatically illegal, and discipline is risky. FEHA protects an employee who, in good faith and reasonably, believed the conduct was unlawful, even if the complaint turns out to be wrong or unsubstantiated. Punishing a good-faith complainant is retaliation.

There is a narrow exception. In Joaquin v. City of Los Angeles (2012) 202 Cal. App. 4th 1207, an officer was fired after a hearing board found that his harassment complaint was a fabrication. The Court of Appeal held that an employer may discipline an employee for false charges, even where the subject matter is sexual harassment. The reason for the termination was the falsity, not the complaint.

Keep these cautions in mind:

  • Fabrication needs proof. A failure of proof doesn't count.

  • Documentation must predate the decision and show how you concluded the complaint was knowingly false.

Our guide to defending a retaliation claim after a documented firing explains why the timing of documentation decides these cases.

Can an Accused Employee Sue Over a Harassment Investigation?

Potentially, depending on what was communicated, to whom, whether the statements were true or privileged, and whether the privilege was defeated by malice.

Defamation claims arising from good-faith complaints are subject to the common-interest privilege under Civil Code §47(c), a conditional privilege for communications made without malice to people with a shared interest. In Bierbower v. FHP, Inc., the Court of Appeal held that a discrepancy in an office memo was insufficient to establish malice and overcome the privilege in a harassment investigation. Suing a complainant also invites a retaliation claim, so involve counsel before anyone threatens a lawsuit.

The risk can also run in the other direction: an accused employee may challenge how an investigation was documented or communicated.

In Hearn v. Pacific Gas & Electric Co. (2025) 108 Cal.App.5th 301, a jury found PG&E liable for defamation based on a report prepared during an employee misconduct investigation. The jury found the challenged statements were not substantially true and that the investigator acted with malice. The report omitted or minimized mitigating information, including evidence concerning workplace practices and supervisory approval relevant to the employee's conduct. The jury awarded $2.16 million.

The Court of Appeal ultimately reversed the defamation judgment because the damages sought were tied to the employee's termination and were not separately recoverable under the circumstances of the case. But the decision still illustrates an important employer-side lesson: investigative reports should accurately reflect material evidence, including significant facts that run counter to the employer's preferred conclusion.

What Makes a California Harassment Investigation Defensible?

Cotran v. Rollins Hudig Hall International, Inc. (1998) provides an important California framework for evaluating an employer's investigation and misconduct determination, particularly where the employer's right to terminate depends on a good-cause standard. 

The broader employer best practice is consistent with current California CRD guidance: investigate promptly, fairly, and impartially; give the accused a meaningful opportunity to respond; evaluate relevant evidence; and document the basis for the decision.

Step

What It Proves

Common Failure

Written notice of allegations to the accused

Fair process

Springing a termination meeting

Interviews of both sides and witnesses

Substantial evidence

Interviewing only the complainant

Chance to respond to adverse evidence

Good faith

Skipping the accused's side

Neutral decision-maker

No pre-judgment

Investigator also advocates a result

Balanced written findings, including mitigating facts

Defamation protection

One-sided reports (the Hearn problem)

Need-to-know distribution only

Privilege preserved

Findings shared in staff meetings

What If the Accused Employee Is Disciplined or Fired and Sues You?

Your investigation record is your defense. The Cotran factors are what courts use to evaluate your process, so a one-sided or rushed investigation can lead to a wrongful termination claim by the accused. Separate the investigator from the decision-maker, apply discipline consistently, and record the reasons at the time. Our wrongful termination defense guide includes a pre-termination checklist. The Hybrid / Non-FEHA Claims team defends wrongful termination and defamation claims that arise this way.

How Do You Defend a Harassment Claim When the Evidence Doesn't Support It?

Build the defense from the facts and the file:

  1. Compare the allegations against contemporaneous evidence, such as messages, schedules, badge or time records, and witness accounts.

  2. Document inconsistencies in the complainant's timeline without attacking the complainant.

  3. Show your prevention and response record: harassment policy, required training, reporting channels, prompt investigation, corrective action where appropriate, and anti-retaliation measures.

  4. Avoid retaliation, since it is often the claim that survives when the harassment claim fails.

  5. Respond to demand letters through counsel. Our guide on responding to an employee demand letter explains how to do so.

CRD generally requires employment complaints to be submitted within three years of the last alleged harm. Employers should nevertheless follow a broader records-retention policy and preserve potentially relevant documents when a complaint, investigation, demand, agency charge, or litigation warrants it.

What California Employers Should Not Do After a Harassment Complaint

  • Don't label the complaint “false” before the investigation.

  • Don't discourage the employee from pursuing the complaint.

  • Don't promise absolute confidentiality.

  • Don't let the accused manager investigate themselves.

  • Don't selectively interview only witnesses who support the employer's preferred outcome.

  • Don't destroy or alter relevant communications.

  • Don't discipline the complainant simply because the allegation cannot be substantiated.

  • Don't distribute the investigation report unnecessarily.

  • Don't write conclusory statements such as “the employee is a liar” when the evidence only establishes inconsistencies.

  • Don't make unrelated employment decisions without checking for the risk of retaliation.

The FEHA / EEO Defense team defends employers against harassment claims at the CRD, the EEOC, and in court.

Conclusion

A California employer should never treat an unsubstantiated harassment complaint as a fabricated one without evidence supporting that conclusion. The defensible approach is to investigate promptly, evaluate the evidence impartially, document the findings, protect against retaliation, and limit investigation communications to those who need to know.

If the evidence does not substantiate the allegation, that does not automatically mean the complainant acted improperly. If the evidence establishes a knowingly fabricated complaint, however, California law does not grant the employee immunity from discipline simply because the complaint involved harassment.

The distinction matters. So does the investigation record supporting it.

If an employee has filed a harassment complaint with the CRD or EEOC, an attorney has sent a demand letter, or an accused employee has threatened legal action, DefendMyBiz offers a free 15-minute consultation. If the complaint is still internal and you want legal review of the investigation before taking action, DefendMyBiz also offers a paid 1-hour consultation. We represent employers only.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a false accusation of harassment illegal?

Can I fire an employee for a false harassment complaint in California?

Can an accused employee sue for defamation?

What makes a harassment investigation fair in California?

What if the evidence is inconclusive?

Disclaimer: The above content is for informational purposes only. This is not legal or tax advice. Laws, IRS guidance, and withholding requirements can change, and outcomes depend on specific facts. You are advised to contact a qualified attorney for any legal advice.